nothing about this has to do with heat, catalysis, or anything else you mentioned. why would you be under NDA for something you clearly have no clue about?
what you’re experiencing is a blatant, grave lack of education and competence, but don’t despair: it’s usually treatable.
No, however, cannabis production culture, outside of universities, has the most curious and open atmosphere of sharing information especially from unique sources that most people would not have considered.
What do you mean emergent phenomena? The emergent property, as I understand it, is that the final state is not explained by the structure of the system that produced it. Which crystallization is not, however, it is so sensitive that it is impossible/nearly impossible to predict the final state from initial conditions, but this is probably an issue with computational power and sampling techniques.
how does evaporation not have to do with heat? How does concentration not have to do with catalysis?
Also, certain industries have developed polymers to prevent crystallization of compounds over super saturation concentrations because they need concentrations of a molecule over super saturation and not crystallization, i.e. drug delivery. At least that’s the only one I know of. AbbieV has a patent on this technology. That polymer only works at a certain concentration. To achieve concentration changes you either add more or reduce volume. So how doesn’t it have to do with.
I think you missed the parts about complexity and dynamics.
“Which crystallization is not,”
When you say “ crystallization (process) is not (complex), What do you mean? Are you implying that the process is conservative or dissipative? Certainly volume is not conserved.??? Mass transfer occurs, so the system is open. Are all the flows and forces , including Onsager’s cross couplings really observable?
The dynamics of crystallization process are certainly not encoded in the equilibrium end state.???
I didn’t say its not complex, I said it’s not an emergent phenomenon. Like ecology and economics have emergent properties. Crystallization isn’t emergent, it only seems emergent because it is very complex and dynamic and you can’t necessarily track all the relevant variables, at least not well until recently, so maybe it seems emergent, but it isn’t.
I guess I should define emergent
" In philosophy, systems theory, science, and art, emergence occurs when a complex entity has properties or behaviors that its parts do not have on their own, and emerge only when they interact in a wider whole"
I guess I should define how I’m using the word catalysis too: a shift in the system that causes a chemical reaction/process to start. Heat isn’t lowering the activation energy or changing a rate of reaction, it is causing the reaction to start. Is that were the confusion is coming from?
I don’t really understand what the hostility is coming from? I mean are you just triggered cause I used the phrase NDA and some multi syllable words and your conditioning from being in prison is making you lash out at anyone who uses big words? I’m not trying to argue semantics here boys.
I’m just like confused by how the one dude is losing his mind, I’m wondering if there is a language barrier or something.
I am not trying to be hostile at all.
I am seriously trying to define the crystallization process. There is some recent work on information flow and human concepts of Causality, I am sort of saying, if crystallization is an emergent phenomena, what conversation can we have if the information is beyond our horizon?
So you are saying you are studying an aqueous solution of a given solute you can not describe. Can you say the solute is soluble? Can we assume it is soluble at a lower temperature and insoluble at a higher. ?
General consensus is that crystallization is an example of weak emergence.
“Sometimes “emergent” is simply used to mean “coming into being.” When used in a more technical sense, though, conceptions of emergent phenomena are often divided between “weak” and “strong.”Cases of weak emergence would imply that the whole only appears to exceed the sum of its parts, but with enough knowledge the equation would even out. Weakly emergent systems are difficult to track and predict due to their complexity, but not because their nature is fundamentally new. Some philosophers even contend that all apparent emergence is weak — that it is largely an illusion brought about by the limitations of human perspective and knowledge.
Strong emergence applies to systems where the whole really is more than the sum of its parts — meaning that the emergent property cannot be understood or predicted based only on an understanding of its components. Evidence for strong emergence could include the appearance of novel physical laws or global phenomena (such as the asymmetry of time, or superconductivity). Some have argued that chemistry itself is an example of strong emergence, since chemical properties do not seem to be not fully derivable from the subatomic particles involved.“